• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Join Self-Employed Australia
  • Protected Members
    • Tax Audit Support
    • Unfair Contract Help
  • About US
    • Who We Are
    • SEA Board
    • Annual Reports
    • No Spam Policy
    • Content Disclaimer
  • Contact Us
  • Log in/Log out
  • Update your details

Self Employed Australia

"Everyone needs an Advocate"

“Everyone needs an Advocate”

  • Current Advocacy
    • Reforming the ATO
    • Small Business Tax Tribunal
    • Fair Contracts
    • Fixing Disputes/Prompt Payment
    • The ‘Gig’ Economy
  • Past Advocacy
    • Submissions
    • Defending ABN Contractors
    • Work Safety
    • Independent Contractors Act
    • Owner-Drivers
    • International Labour Organisation
    • Independent Contractors: How Many?
  • SEA Submissions
    • Submissions
    • Independent Contractors: How Many?
  • Members-only Articles
    • About ICA
    • Contract Design and Templates
    • Independent Contractors Act
    • Practical Assistance
    • Taxation Matters
    • What is an Independent Contractor?
  • News Categories
  • NotAboveTheLaw

ATO relies on ‘gossip’ to manufacture tax debt, defiling the rule of law

May 2, 2021 by Self-Employed Australia

An April 2021 High Court outcome demonstrates that the ATO has chucked the rule of law into the bin. The ATO asserts that it can manufacture a tax debt based on gossip.

Between 2012 and 2015, criminals defrauded the ATO of at least $2.45 billion in GST in the ‘gold scam’. In happened arguably because of ATO incompetence. We’ve explained this before.

In our view, to cover its tracks, the ATO is attacking innocent parties.

Around 2016 the ATO withheld GST refunds of around $209 million due to a large gold refiner. The ATO knew that the big refiner was not part of the GST gold scam. The ATO won in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The basis of the ATO win was (hold on to your hats) that emails between two people, not associated with the refinery company, discussed issues around the gold scam.

This email exchange amounted to gossip and hearsay, contained no evidence and was essentially idle chat between the people involved and was ‘hidden’ amongst 44,000 pages of ‘evidence.’ The persons were never questioned.

The company appealed to the Full Bench of the Federal Court and won (November 2020). In layperson’s language, the Federal Court effectively said that reliance on gossip to ‘invent’ a tax debt was nonsense.

But the ATO took a further step that demonstrates just what a threat it poses to justice and the rule of law in Australia.

The ATO went to the High Court and asked the High Court to consider that the AAT ruling was correct. Think of that. In seeking ‘leave to appeal’ to the High Court, the ATO was saying that it has the right and legal capacity to invent a tax debt based on gossip.

In other words, if there were, for example, a Twitter or Facebook haranguing session between two people you did not know and they were saying that you were a tax cheat, then that would be enough for the ATO to declare you a tax cheat. The ATO could then raise a tax debt against you and proceed to collect that ‘debt’ by raiding your bank account.

This is not how justice in a rule-of-law society operates. Justice is based on facts and truth which are tested by examination and cross-examination. We are not held responsible for what we have not done because someone makes a gossipy comment.

Thank goodness the High Court rejected this ATO application. The company is not guilty. Gossip does not rule.

But consider further. The ATO has spent in excess of $40 million on legal fees pushing this case. Ordinary taxpayers and small business people cannot defend themselves against such ATO aggression.

In asserting its right to raise tax debts based on gossip the ATO is saying that it is the law and not subject to the rule of law.

This cannot be allowed to continue. Justice must prevail. We need action if tax justice is to be delivered in Australia. The case for reforming the ATO just keeps getting stronger.

Filed Under: News Updates, Taxation

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Is your superannuation money safe? Morrison v Albanese May 17, 2022
  • Morrison’s dead flat small business pitch May 11, 2022
  • Albanese plan to smash Australia’s 2 million self-employed May 5, 2022
  • Closing the construction watchdog will harm self-employed tradies April 24, 2022
  • ATO ramps up its aggressive campaign against small and family businesses April 14, 2022
  • Government gets massive tax windfall from Australians who have received no income. Bastards! April 8, 2022
  • For goodness’ sake stop wearing those same pyjamas at work! April 3, 2022
  • Update – Hotel Quarantine Prosecution – Supreme Court Victoria – A bit boring but important! March 21, 2022
  • Confronting bullies in our own (Australian) backyard – Unfair Contracts March 3, 2022
  • We lodge court action against WorkSafe Victoria. No-one should be above the law February 15, 2022

Categories

Footer

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2022 · News Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in