• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • Content Disclaimer
  • Contact Us

Self Employed Australia

"Everyone needs an Advocate"

“Everyone needs an Advocate”

  • Current Advocacy
    • Reforming the ATO
    • Fair Contracts
    • Fixing Disputes/Prompt Payment
    • The ‘Gig’ Economy
  • Past Advocacy
    • Submissions
    • Defending ABN Contractors
    • Work Safety
    • Independent Contractors Act
    • Owner-Drivers
    • International Labour Organisation
    • Independent Contractors: How Many?
  • SEA Submissions
    • Submissions
    • Independent Contractors: How Many?
  • NotAboveTheLaw
    • Robodebt
    • Hotel Quarantine 2020
    • Chemical Fire 2019
  • Be Your Own Boss

California AB5

Victorian Labor promises to destroy gig work and self-employment

November 21, 2022 by Self-Employed Australia

destroy-gig-workIn late October this year the Victorian Labor Government announced new gig laws it intends to introduce. The promised laws have all the nice-sounding language of ‘rights’ for gig self-employed people, but in fact the laws amount to a stripping of rights.

We’ve seen this sort of cunning stuff before. In California, in 2020, new laws came into effect that outlawed the use of self-employed people. That is, the structure of the laws didn’t ban people being their own boss. But by making it illegal to use self-employed people, California destroyed the incomes of people who worked as their own boss.

The promised Victorian Labor laws would perform a similar underhand trick. Effectively the laws would impose huge union control and centralised regulation over gig platforms, thereby destroying their business models. The platforms would become unprofitable and be forced to leave Victoria.

This is why Deliveroo recently closed in Australia. They’d done deals with unions that made their business unviable. Close down was the answer!

And who suffers? Yep, you got it. It’s the thousands of self-employed people—try students, retirees and the rest—who use gig platforms to top up their income. Only 0.19 percent of gig workers use gig for their full-time work. Everyone else uses gig for income top-up.

The promised Victorian Labor law is a business destroyer. It’s a policy that says that Labor despises people who work as their own boss, working when they want to work. It’s a policy of hate toward small business people.

We saw this before in Victoria when, around 2017, the Victorian Labor Government forced the breaking of the contracts of hundreds of self-employed cleaners who had direct contracts to clean schools. Labor forced these ‘own boss’ cleaners out of business and handed the contracts to big business. Cleaners were forced to become union members or have no work.

The promised Victorian Labor gig destruction laws would:

  • Force gig platforms into industrial-style ‘negotiations’ over how they manage their business and what the terms of their contracts are. This process would give unions power over gig platforms and gig workers.
  • Force gig platforms to change their contracts.
  • Destroy the entire concept and practice of ‘offer and acceptance of contract’ which is the core fundamental of commercial activity.
  • Impose pay rates.

And more.

In effect, self-employed gig people would retain their theoretical ‘right’ to be self-employed. But gig work and income would simply disappear. This is a Labor policy that attacks the ability of low-income people to find income through being their own boss. It’s pretty disgusting!


This commentary should in no way be construed or taken as an endorsement (or otherwise) of any political candidate or party or as a suggestion as to how anyone should vote or not vote at the 26 November Victorian state election. 

Filed Under: 'Insecure Work', California AB5, Defining Self-employment, News Updates, Rule of law, Self-Employed Australia, Self-employment, The Gig Economy, The nature of work

In London on joint international self-employed defence campaign

September 15, 2022 by Self-Employed Australia

London-QueenI’ve been in London over the last week-and-a-bit. We (SEA) have a long association with several UK self-employed associations and have been working with them on common issues to defend self-employed people. Hence the London presence.

The two big issues are:

  • The UK tax authority’s (HMRC’s) unfair treatment of self-employed people. (Sound familiar to the ATO??)
  • Identifying whether an individual is an employee or self-employed and what ‘rights’ each has.

Reforming tax administration

After many months of planning we were lined up for meetings/presentations with UK MPs in Westminster. These meetings were to discuss how HMRC could be reformed along the lines that we’re campaigning on for reform of the ATO. That is, using the USA laws covering the IRS as a template. However, the passing of the Queen and her funeral have meant that all these meetings were cancelled. Once the Royal transition is complete and the UK Parliament starts operating again, we’ll be working with our partners to re-initiate the campaign.

Our aim is to see if we can get a common movement in UK and Australia for reform of the HMRC and ATO. The treatment of self-employed people by both administrations is terrible, and their intimidatory behaviours share similar features. With a joint campaign effort we may increase our chances of achieving fairness for self-employed people.

Self-employed status and ‘rights’

We did, however, go ahead with a planned workshop session on self-employed status and ‘rights’. Included in this workshop were like-minded friends from the USA. This issue is ‘hot’ in the UK and USA (think California outlawing self-employment). Even though the media were present, we’ve recorded the workshop and presentation and will also release this once the Royal transition is complete. This issue has great importance for the UK, the USA and Australia. In Australia the Albanese government is committed to ‘smashing’ the self-employed. And the Albanese government, we predict, is likely to replicate very confusing UK ‘little bit pregnant’ laws to achieve its aims.

We’ll have a lot more to say about this and to explain the issues over the coming weeks/months. But at this stage we’re putting together a UK/USA/Oz ‘team’ to focus on the common themes to defend the right of people to be self-employed. We’ve gotta be organised!

More soon.

Filed Under: 'Insecure Work', California AB5, Defining Self-employment, Independent contracting, News Updates, Rule of law, Self-employment, Tax Reform, The nature of work

California Attacks Santa Claus – A Victorian Agenda?

December 22, 2020 by Self-Employed Australia

Tuesday, December 22, 2020

We’ve covered before the weird laws in California (called AB5) that have made self-employment illegal. On the evidence, it seems that these laws have pushed California’s unemployment rate to 50 per cent higher than the US average. The laws came into force on 1 January this year. But it’s now impacting on Christmas.

Patrick Turnbull has been a Californian Santa for 20 years. He doesn’t work as Santa all year round. That’s logical. Not much Santa work outside Christmas! So, he’s worked as an independent contractor Santa. Now the Californian AB5 law say that’s wrong. In this 4-minute video, Patrick (Santa) Turnbull explains why denying him his Santa ‘rights’ is so bad.

You tell ’em Santa! (click the image for the YouTube video):

What’s worrying is that Dan Andrews’ Victorian government also has an anti-Santa (independent contractor) agenda. We’ve told the government in very blunt terms, ‘leave us alone … we have a right to be self-employed.’ We ‘demand’ the right to be Santa if we want!! Viva la Santa revolution!

Oh yeh. And Merry Christmas! We all deserve it this year.

Filed Under: California AB5, Campaigns, Defending the gig economy, Self-employment

Anti-Trump Democrats get political black eye from small business

May 28, 2020 by Self-Employed Australia

Thursday, May 28, 2020

The anti-Trump forces in the USA have just suffered a surprise defeat in a Californian bye-election that has likely implications for the November US Presidential election.

The Democrats suffered a massive backlash against them because of vicious anti-small business laws that have crushed the self-employed small business sector in California.

The law (AB5) started on 1 January this year and essentially outlawed self-employment in California. It’s caused havoc with huge job losses, large numbers leaving the state and economic collapse in independent contractor industry sectors. This bad job wave swept across California just before the Covid-19 disaster.

The Democrats who control the California legislature and created the anti-self-employed laws have responded with arrogance. Go get a union ‘employment’ job they say! Self-employment’s not a ‘real’ job the Democrats claim. Voters have thought differently.

The political power cards play out as follows.

In the US Federal Congress (parliament) the Trump Republicans control the Senate (upper house). But the anti-Trump Democrats control the (lower) House of Representatives with 235 seats to the Republicans’ 197 seats. This Democrat control of the House of Representatives frustrates and limits the Trump agenda. California is the key state giving Democrats their control.

Of the 435 seats in the House, 53 come from California. The Democrats have 46 of those seats. If the Trump Republicans were to win 20 seats from the Democrats and Trump remained President, Trump would control the US Congress. The Californian Democrats’ hatred of small business raises just that scenario: a Trump Presidential and Congressional win.

Just a week ago a Republican Trump loyalist won a bye-election for a Californian House seat, defeating the incumbent Democrat with a 19 per cent swing. A bye-election ‘flip’ of this sort has not happened in California since 1998, let alone one with a swing of this size.

The Trump Republican candidate campaigned hard against the Californian Democrats’ anti-small business law (AB5).

The national implications are clear. The Democrats’ Presidential candidate, Joe Biden, has endorsed California’s AB5, promising to take it across America if he wins. The Trump Republicans will campaign saying Democrat Biden will destroy small business across America. It’s powerful political messaging underpinned by the glaring reality of California’s AB5.

The Democrats have dug themselves into a deep hole. Their actions speak of hatred of self-employed, small business people.

What unfolds in the USA with the November Presidential and Congressional elections over the rights of self-employed people holds potential lessons for Australia—namely, can a political party attack self-employed, small business people and survive politically? Watch this space!

Filed Under: California AB5, Campaigns, Defending the gig economy, News Updates, Self-employment, USA

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • SEA historical website January 31, 2024
  • Closed doors January 31, 2024
  • We ask you: Make your views known to independent Senators! — Urgent January 9, 2024
  • We ask Senator Pocock: Does he support the outlawing of self-employment? January 5, 2024
  • Ooops! Common sense turns into double-cross. Trojan Horse December 14, 2023
  • Loophole Update – Common sense at last – Movement! December 7, 2023
  • Dancing with Alice at the Mad Hatter’s tea party – Loophole Bill farce November 29, 2023
  • Thank goodness for the independents! Loophole Bill is a huge PILL November 24, 2023
  • Loophole Bill – State of play November 20, 2023
  • You don’t save something by destroying it! November 13, 2023

Categories

Copyright © 2025 · News Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in