• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Join Self-Employed Australia
  • Protected Members
    • Tax Audit Support
    • Unfair Contract Help
  • About US
    • Who We Are
    • Annual Reports
    • No Spam Policy
    • Content Disclaimer
  • Contact Us
  • Log in/Log out
  • Update your details

Self Employed Australia

"Everyone needs an Advocate"

“Everyone needs an Advocate”

  • Current Advocacy
    • Reforming the ATO
    • Fair Contracts
    • Fixing Disputes/Prompt Payment
    • The ‘Gig’ Economy
  • Past Advocacy
    • Submissions
    • Defending ABN Contractors
    • Work Safety
    • Independent Contractors Act
    • Owner-Drivers
    • International Labour Organisation
    • Independent Contractors: How Many?
  • SEA Submissions
    • Submissions
    • Independent Contractors: How Many?
  • Members-only
    • About ICA
    • Contract Design and Templates
    • Independent Contractors Act
    • Practical Assistance
    • Taxation Matters
    • What is an Independent Contractor?
  • News Categories
  • NotAboveTheLaw
    • Robodebt
    • Hotel Quarantine 2020
    • Chemical Fire 2019
  • Be Your Own Boss

Could the ATO have attempted to ‘pervert the course of justice’? Judge asks

November 3, 2017 by Self-Employed Australia

We work hard to ensure that our criticism of the way the Australian Taxation Office treats self-employed people is based on facts. Our summary of the mistreatment of Rod Douglass we think demonstrates the facts.

And the fact is that what happened to Rod could happen to anyone. This includes consultants, IT and engineering professionals, tradies, even home-based small business people.

But what has just occurred is extraordinary.

Michael Shord happens to be a diver working on overseas oil rigs. He is arguing with the ATO over how much tax he owes. Fair enough! His situation is a bit complex. However, a Tribunal made an error in a ruling. The ATO knew this. But when Michael tried to get the error fixed, the ATO opposed this in higher Courts.

In a Full Federal Court judgment last week Justice Logan said: (brackets and emphasized words are ours)

the “…denial of procedural fairness to Mr Shord … is patent.”

and

“…the Commissioner (Tax) should not just have not opposed the amendment (fixing the error) but readily consented to it…”

Justice Logan then said of the ATO’s behaviour in opposing the fix,

“…Departures from model litigant behaviour can, in particular circumstances, constitute professional misconduct, a contempt of court or an attempt, contrary to s 43 of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), to pervert the course of justice.”

This is arguably an extraordinary judicial criticism, almost a warning to the ATO.

However, Justice Logan then stated

“…it appears to me that the lack of a ready concession of the jurisdictional error was just the result of a lack of understanding…”

Prior to stating the above, Justice Logan demonstrated an acute understanding of history and the foundations upon which a just society sits. And further, how lack of integrity and honesty by tax authorities can crumble those foundations. His comments are thoughtful. Read them here.

Justice Logan’s analysis reminds us of the importance of our campaign for reform of the ATO. It’s not just about self-employed people but the very integrity of our society.

Here are links to a summary of last week’s judgment and the judgment itself. Also, here’s a quick YouTube summary.

Robert Gottliebsen in The Australian has also commented on the case: ‘Federal Court judge warns tax Commissioner’

Understanding both Rod’s case and Michael Shord’s will better prepare you when you’re faced with a Tax Audit.

Filed Under: Campaigns, Michael Shord, Reforming the ATO, Rod Douglass

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Loophole Update – Common sense at last – Movement! December 7, 2023
  • Dancing with Alice at the Mad Hatter’s tea party – Loophole Bill farce November 29, 2023
  • Thank goodness for the independents! Loophole Bill is a huge PILL November 24, 2023
  • Loophole Bill – State of play November 20, 2023
  • You don’t save something by destroying it! November 13, 2023
  • Historic day for small business people – Real unfair contract protections November 9, 2023
  • Update from Parliament: Loophole (IR) Bill November 3, 2023
  • Defend your right (and the right of anyone) to be your own boss October 27, 2023
  • Trashing casuals’ incomes – The Loophole Bill October 23, 2023
  • Independent Senators – Your small business future in their hands October 18, 2023

Categories

Footer

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2023 · News Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in